Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Walt Whitman - "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry"

Walter “Walt” Whitman Bio
      Walter “Walt” Whitman was born on May 31, 1819 in Long Island, New York and grew up in Brooklyn. He contracted a love for writing when he was twelve years old. He taught himself how to read and write through Homer’s, Dante’s and Shakespeare’s work. Throughout Whitman’s life he worked as a printer, teacher, journalist, editor, poet, and clerk for the Department of the Interior. In addition to these jobs, he helped people who were wounded in the Civil War. He stayed in the state of New York the majority of his life and died in Camden, New Jersey on March 26, 1892. Some of his most noted works were Leaves of Grass (1855) and Good-bye, My Fancy (1891). He is considered the father of free-verse. You can read more about Walt Whitman at http://www.poets.org/poet.php/prmPID/126.

Summary
Section 1: Whitman is very observant about the ferry itself, its passengers, and the surrounding scenery.
Section 2: Whitman senses a connection between all of those going about their daily routines. People will continue to use the ships as transportation over the river and will continue to enjoy them. Whitman thinks the rivers and ships will be used for the rest of life in New York City.
Section 3: He describes the environment and atmosphere. He describes how the water and birds in the sky look, as well as the kinds of ships, their parts, and their laborers. He also describes how the ships move through the ports and across the river.
Section 4: He states again the connection and unity between himself and people around him. “Others the same…” meaning people in the future will look back at the moment he is currently living. (They will learn the history of the ferries.)
Section 5: He asks his readers what the connection is between them despite the hundreds of years.
Section 6: Whitman starts writing about his darker times, when he made less honest decisions. He knows he was among the worst people, morally. Before he changed, his life was dull, monotonous, and had no variety.
Section 7: Even though section 7 was very short, what do you think Whitman was trying to portray to his audience?
Section 8: Whitman believes the nature of Manhattan is the most majestic view and that no scenery could be better.
Section 9: Whitman wants to bask in the beauty of nature around him. He wants the mind to be conscious and the city to provoke emotion. He wants to see animation and liveliness in the objects around him, such as the chimneys, birds, and sun.

Questions
1. What is the tone of section 3? What feelings does Whitman convey?

2. Section 5 – Does he mean everyone is literally related to one another and we share the same lineage? Or, does he mean that his readers, however many years in the future, will still have a connection to him? Is there another kind of connection?

3. Even though section 7 was very short, what do you think Whitman was trying to portray to his audience?

4. Section 9, last stanza – “You have waited, you always wait, you dumb, beautiful ministers" Why does he call them dumb? Who are the ministers?

5. What are some archaic words throughout this poem? Was there any repetition that you noticed?

6. What are some of your favorite images Whitman describes?

7. Was there anything that confused you?

8. Do you think the purpose of this poem is to influence your opinion of New York, or did Whitman just want to narrate his experiences and emotions of New York? Do you think there is another purpose?

Twain and Marti

Mark Twain / Personals:  During the time of writing, The Herald was one of the most famous newspaper to read in New York.  He specifically talks about and pokes fun at the "Personals" section.  He briefly analyzes different excerpts in the "Personals" from many men and women.  He reads between the lines and presents his own tongue-in-cheek opinion on what these writers actually meant.  Twain then goes on to say that each writer is a "wooden-headed lout" for thinking that each smile or wave will lead to romance.  Many New Yorkers, in his eyes, are hopeless romantics for writing to and reading the "Personals" so much.  At the end, Twain shows a sadder side to the "Personals," with a short passage simply saying "Come back home."

https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2/22341/024.092.000.webimage.JPEG?sequence=9

Marti / New York Under the Snow: Jose Marti recalls the blizzard of 1888 in New York City.  Throughout the short passage, the blizzard is continually getting worse, as more and more people are succumbing to the terrible storm.  Factory workers are forcing themselves to traverse the horrible conditions to continue with their jobs.  Paperboys are still on the streets, selling their wares in snow up to their chests.  Even the busiest of streets were barren.  Some boys had to hold up signs that stated which street was which.  Many citizens were paying 25 to 50 dollars for one horse-drawn carriage to take them where they needed to go (i.e. a few feet).  Marti focuses on the will of us as human beings to persevere through hardships and trouble.  A fire even broke out during this blizzard, which was problematic for the firefighters.  The fire hydrants were all covered in snow and the wind did not help them in fighting the fire, either.  Marti ends the passage on a lighter note, as he discusses the humility and kindness of the citizens of New York.

http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/The_Blizzard_of_1888%3B_the_Impact_of_this_Devastating_Storm_on_New_York_Transit
 
http://myinwood.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Blizzard-of-1888-r.jpg

Questions:

1) What, if any, examples of the "Personals" do we have today?  Is this made easier with the advancement of the internet.  How is this similar to what Twain was describing.

2) Compare the description of the human spirit as described by both Twain and Marti.  How are they similar?  In what ways are they different?

3) In light of the current weather we have been having, compare the descriptions Marti has over the kindness of strangers in 1888 to today.  Do we still have a will to help others in need during times of adversity?

4) What was your favorite "Personal" that Twain described and why?  What kind of humor does Twain use to describe the "Personals?"

5) Before looking at real-life pictures of the blizzard, do you think Marti exaggerated at all with how much snow was in New York?  After seeing the pictures, can you believe that something this severe happening in America in the 19th century?  Do you feel this could still happen today?

6) Despite the difference in writing styles, Marti and Twain both have a sense of making you fully understand the situation at hand.  What kind of literary elements do both authors use to describe a location or event?  What is unique about either author?  Which one would you prefer to read from in the future?